I don't understand the fierce war taking place on the internet between Amr Diab's and Tamer Hosny's fans! it is becoming redicules begad! People have the right to choose their favorite music, signer, ...etc but i can see that people spend more time attacking each other more than listening to the songs and enjoying the music!I am a fan of Amr Diab since his early albums, and I love his 90s songs. I can spot many beautiful well-prepared songs in his new album specially the ones tackling the non-common issues like friendship after love. Inspite of that, I blame him for dedicating all 12 songs for love, while in his age, he should include more songs about family (like the one Hisham Abbas did for his son), friendship, even polictics (like Tarateer El 3esely),...etc.
On the other hand I don't like Tamer Hosny not because he is bad but because simply I can't relate to him, what he says, or even the composition of his music. This doesn't mean that someone is better than the other. I don't think they should be compared in the first place, same thing like Abel Halim, and Amr Diab, or Um Kalthoum & Abdel Halim.
Why don't everyone enjoys what he/she wants, and let others enjoy theirs too! wala kol 7aga ba2t Ahly we Zamalek!
Mohaly
13 comments:
يعد "وياه" واحد من أجمل ألبومات عمرو دياب، نجح من خلاله في تقديم وجبة غنائية كاملة الدسم بحق.
واتفق الكثيرون أن أجمل ما في الألبوم هو كلمات الأغاني العذبة التي انتقاها دياب بالإضافة إلى الألحان المتميزة والجديدة والتوزيع الرائع للموزع حسن الشافعي الذي يعد اكتشاف عمرو الغنائي رغم صغر سنه الذي لم يتجاوز بعد 27 سنة.
Amr Diab became Egyptian legend..tamer still nothing.
why do we -Egyptians- love to be at one side against the other, what is wrong with neshaga3 el le3ba or el ghenwa el 7elwa?
Amina, I have noticed that too, and that is why I am asking people to enjoy what they have instead of wasting their feelings in meaningless wars!
Of course Raghada and Abdel Aziz, Amr Diab is part of an overall generation experience, and I have all his 24 albums but this shouldn't be a reason for a war against the rest. Note that Tamer's fans are teenagers, and they always want to be different.
يجماعه الاغانى حرام وفيه فرق لما بنكون نسمع الاغانى ونقر ونعترف انها حرام وبين ان احنا نكابر ونقول انها مش حرام بدليل قوله تعالى فى كتابه الكريم(ومن الناس من يشترى لهو الحديث ليضل به عن سبيل الله) واتفق العلماء على ان المقصود بلهو الحديث هنا فى عصرنا الحالى هو الغناء بدليل بسيط اراهن ان كان حد بيسمع اغانى كتير ومندمج اوى كده ان كان بيقرا قراءن او بيذكر ربنا قد ماهو بيسمع اغانى
i just love the new album, lots of songs and ideas, and I agree with you mohaly about that he needs to indtroduce other topics than love.
ya 3am Zeyad, e7na nenet2asar bel quran lama yetratel men kare2 gayed ye2dar yewasal el ma3ani be7alwet soto, we mabne2darsh nesma3o lama beyeb2a beza3a2 aw soto we7esh, we rasoul talab men belal 2eno ye2azen 3ashan soto el gameel ye2der ye7arak el nas men gowa, famatgeesh teo2uli el moseeqa 7aram!
Mohaly, as amr diab is the one for our generation, tamer hosny is the same for the new generations. But the problem as u say it became a fan wars .. i used to like tamer hosny @ the begining abl mayhabel w yefteker nafso valentino :) as he is talented but he is not as smart as amr diab.
I heard someone saying el music 7aram?!
الموسيقى حرام يا عمر و يا أخت مها
may be communication through the web 7aram also ya "akh ziad" !
Anyway, it's your own opinion :)
By the way, anyone saw helmy's new movie ? Let me know if it worth to be seen or not .
Music is a tool that can be used in hallal or 7aram stuff, so it is neutral in nature.
Islam is a religion of mind, so use it!
Becuase peopel -majority not all- are very narrow minded; each claim that he/she/they have the ultimate truth, do the ultimate right while others are "rubbish" so they don't know how to accept the other opinion and deal with it.
Couple of days ago, I wrote a post entitled Tunnel Vision which might be an answer for this question and others too!
Post a Comment